Damn I wish I could write like Lileks. Writing about Revenge of the Sith, he hit all of the high and low points of the movie. Especially the part about how the movie would be better if it were silent with only sound effects and score. Flash the dialog on the screen with frames or subtitles, and the total effect would be the same. Suggestion for the special edition DVD: give the option for just that, Turn off dialog, activate subtitles.